All-America
| First Team | Publication |
| Joaquin Gonzalez, OT | FWAA, BCSfootball.com |
| Bryant McKinnie, OT | Football News, CNNSI.com |
| Dan Morgan, LB | FWAA, Football News, Walter Camp team, College Football News, The Sporting News, CNNSI.com |
| Santana Moss, KR | FWAA, College Football News, The Sporting News, CNNSI.com |
| Santana Moss, WR | Walter Camp team |
| Edward Reed, FS | FWAA, CNNSI.com, BCSfootball.com |
| Second Team | Publication |
| Joaquin Gonzalez, OT | Associated Press, College Football News |
| Edward Reed, FS | Football News, College Football News |
| Third Team | Publication |
| Damione Lewis, DT | The Sporting News |
| Honorable Mention | Publication |
| Ken Dorsey, QB | Football News, CNNSI.com |
| Damione Lewis, DT | Football News |
| Joaquin Gonzalez, OT | CNNSI.com |
| Santana Moss, WR | Football News, CNNSI.com |
| Jeremy Shockey, TE | CNNSI.com |
Freshman All-America
| First Team | Publication |
| Jonathan Vilma | Rivals.com |
| Honorable Mention | Publication |
| D.J. Williams, FB | Rivals.com |
Academic All-America
| First Team | Publication |
| Joaquin Gonzalez, OT | GTE/CoSIDA |
All-BIG EAST
| First Team | Publication |
| Al Blades, SS | Official BIG EAST Conference, The Sporting News |
| Freddie Capshaw, P | Official BIG EAST Conference, The Sporting News, Football News |
| Ken Dorsey, QB | Official BIG EAST Conference, College Football News, The Sporting News, Football News |
| Joaquin Gonzalez, OT | Official BIG EAST Conference, College Football News, The Sporting News |
| Damione Lewis, DT | Official BIG EAST Conference*, College Football News, The Sporting News, Football News |
| Bryant McKinnie, OT | Official BIG EAST Conference, College Football News, football News |
| Dan Morgan, LB | Official BIG EAST Conference*, College Football News, The Sporting News, Football News |
| Santana Moss, WR | Official BIG EAST Conference, College Football News, The Sporting News, Football News |
| Santana Moss, KR/PR | Official BIG EAST Conference |
| Edward Reed, FS | Official BIG EAST Conference, College Football News, The Sporting News, Football News |
| Mike Rumph, CB | Official BIG EAST Conference |
| Brett Romberg, C | The Sporting News |
| Jeremy Shockey, TE | Official BIG EAST Conference, College Football News, The Sporting News |
| Todd Sievers, K | The Sporting News |
| Second Team | Publication |
| James Jackson, RB | Official BIG EAST Conference |
| Daryl Jones, KR/PR | The Sporting News |
| Leonard Myers, CB | Official BIG EAST Conference |
| Bryant McKinnie, OT | The Sporting News |
| Reggie Wayne, WR | Official BIG EAST Conference, The Sporting News |
| Honors | Award | Publication | |
| Butch Davis, HC | BIG EAST Coach of the Year | Official BIG EAST Conference | |
| BIG EAST Coach of the Year | College Football News | ||
| BIG EAST Coach of the Year | The Sporting News | ||
| Region 1 Coach of the Year | American Football Coaches’ Association | ||
| Dan Morgan, LB | Bronko Nagurski Trophy | FWAA, Touchdown Club of Charlotte (NC) | |
| Defensive Player of the Year | Official BIG EAST Conference* | ||
| Defensive Player of the Year | Football News | ||
| Defensive Player of the Year | College Football News | ||
| Defensive Player of the Year | BCSfootball.com | ||
| Linebacker of the Year | Touchdown Club of Columbus (OH) | ||
| Santana Moss, WR | Offensive Player of the Year | Official BIG EAST Conference | |
| Paul Warfield Trophy | Touchdown Club of Columbus (OH) | ||
| Santana Moss, KR/PR | Special Teams Player of the Year | Official BIG EAST Conference* | |
* Unanimous Selection
Note: Dan Morgan is a finalist for the Butkus and Bednarik defensive awards.