Football History: All-Americans
| Only First Team All-American Honorees who were selected by the Associated Press, American Football Coaches Association, Football Writers Association of America, Sporting New and/or Walter Camp Football Foundation | |||
| First Name | Last Name | Position | Year |
| Al | Carapella | T | 1950 |
| Jim | Dooley | HB | 1951 |
| Nick | Chickillo | G | 1952 |
| Frank | McDonald | WR | 1954 |
| Don | Bosseler | FB | 1956 |
| Fran | Curci | QB | 1959 |
| Bill | Miller | WR | 1960-61 |
| George | Mira Sr. | QB | 1962-63 |
| Dan | Conners | T | 1963 |
| Ed | Weisacosky | DE | 1965 |
| Ted | Hendricks | DE | 1966-68 |
| Tom | Beier | DB | 1966 |
| Harold | Sears | LB | 1971 |
| Chuck | Foreman | RB | 1972 |
| Burgess | Owens | DB | 1972 |
| Tony | Cristiani | DL | 1972-73 |
| Rubin | Carter | DL | 1974 |
| Dennis | Harrah | T | 1974 |
| Eddie | Edwards | DT | 1976 |
| Don | Latimer | DL | 1977 |
| Don | Smith | DT | 1978 |
| Jim | Burt | DL | 1980 |
| Fred | Marion | DB | 1981 |
| Danny | Miller | K | 1981 |
| Lester | Williams | DT | 1981 |
| Jay | Brophy | LB | 1983 |
| Eddie | Brown | WR | 1984 |
| Willie | Smith | TE | 1985 |
| Jerome | Brown | DT | 1986 |
| Vinny | Testaverde | QB | 1986 |
| Bennie | Blades | DB | 1986-87 |
| Daniel | Stubbs | DE | 1987 |
| Cleveland | Gary | RB | 1988 |
| Bill | Hawkins | DE | 1988 |
| Steve | Walsh | QB | 1988 |
| Greg | Mark | DE | 1989 |
| Maurice | Crum | LB | 1990 |
| Russell | Maryland | DT | 1990 |
| Carlos | Huerta | K | 1991 |
| Leon | Searcy | T | 1991 |
| Darrin | Smith | LB | 1991-92 |
| Darryl | Williams | FS | 1991 |
| Kevin | Williams | WR/KR | 1991 |
| Michael | Barrow | LB | 1992 |
| Ryan | McNeil | DB | 1992 |
| Gino | Torretta | QB | 1992 |
| Kevin | Patrick | DE | 1993 |
| CJ | Richardson | S | 1994 |
| Warren | Sapp | DT | 1994 |
| Ray | Lewis | LB | 1995 |
| KC | Jones | C | 1996 |
| Richard | Mercier | G | 1999 |
| Daniel “Bubba” | Franks | TE | 1999 |
| Dan | Morgan | LB | 2000 |
| Santana | Moss | WR/PR | 2000 |
| Joaquin | Gonzalez | T | 2000-01 |
| Bryant | McKinnie | T | 2000-01 |
| Edward | Reed | S | 2000-01 |
| Phillip | Buchanon | CB/PR | 2001 |
| Jeremy | Shockey | TE | 2001 |
| Todd | Seivers | K | 2001 |
| Ken | Dorsey | QB | 2002 |
| Jerome | McDougle | DE | 2002 |
| Willis | McGahee | RB | 2002 |
| Brett | Romberg | C | 2002 |
| Sean | Taylor | FS | 2003 |
| Kellen | Winslow | TE | 2003 |
| Antrel | Rolle | CB | 2004 |
| Devin | Hester | CB | 2004 |
| Eric | Winston | T | 2005 |
| Brandon | Meriweather | S | 2005 |
| Kelly | Jennings | CB | 2005 |
